New approach to North Coast environmental zones
By EDO NSW Outreach Solicitor Nina Lucas
23 October 2015
The NSW Government has announced key changes to the way that councils can set land aside for environmental conservation and management in the Far North Coast area of NSW. The changes weaken environmental protections and may have State-wide implications.
The NSW Minister for Planning has announced key changes to the way that councils can set land aside for environmental conservation and management under Local Environmental Plans (LEPs) in the Ballina, Byron, Kyogle, Lismore and Tweed Local Government Areas (LGAs). These changes are significant for the Far North Coast environment, and carry the potential for State-wide environmental implications.
The changes, which are set out in the Northern Councils E Zone Review Final Recommendations Report, water down these five councils’ ability to zone land for environmental conservation and management. The changes also offer weaker environmental protections than those proposed in the interim report released by the Department of Planning and Environment for public comment in June 2014.
Wilson River, Lismore
Why have these changes been made?
This announcement is the latest development in a three-year review of the way that environmental zones (E zones), which include E2 (environmental conservation), E3 (environmental management) and E4 (environmental living), as well as environmental overlays in LEPs, are applied by councils on the Far North Coast. The review arose following perceived conflicts between agricultural and environmental uses of land in the region, and from apparent concerns that Far North Coast councils were introducing E zones on land previously zoned for rural use without evidence of the environmental significance of the land.
The Far North Coast is one of the most biologically diverse regions in NSW and agriculture is a major part of the regional economy. See our previous article for a history of the review, and read more about the background to these recommendations in our court case challenging amendments to Lismore LEP.
Where do the changes apply?
While the review only applied to the Far North Coast, any other council in the State reviewing the application of E zones in its own LGA can apply the recommendations contained in the report. The Department has also indicated that a similar approach to the application of E zones is being considered for other council areas across NSW.
Where can E zones be applied under the changes?
Councils are now only be able to apply E zones to land that is deemed to be of very high conservation value, such as certain recognised littoral rainforest, certain coastal wetlands, key threatened species habitat, and rare, endangered and vulnerable forest ecosystems. Scenic values can no longer be used as an attribute for the application of an E2 or E3 zone or mapped planning controls. In addition to this, the ‘primary use’ of the land needs to have been either environmental conservation (E2) or environmental management (E3) for the preceding two years before it can be zoned E2 or E3.
Extensive agriculture will now be permitted with consent in the E2 zone and permitted without consent in E3 zones in the relevant LGAs, and the E zones will not include buffers to the vegetation attributes that meet the E zone criteria.
Biodiversity field inspections and ground surveys are required in order to verify whether the land meets the criteria in order to be zoned as E2 or E3. Even if land is verified as having met the criteria for an E zone, it is not mandatory for the council to apply an E2 or E3 zone to it. If the council believes the intended primary use of the land does not warrant an E zone, then other mapped planning controls can be applied. In most cases, privately-owned land will not have an E2 or E3 zone applied to it unless the landowner agrees or requests it.
The Department is considering a revision of the Standard Instrument LEP to remove ‘aesthetic values’ from the zone objectives of the E2 and E3 zones. The possibility of an amendment to NSW planning legislation to remove or extend the 12 month time limit which extinguishes existing use rights for the land use ‘extensive agriculture’ is also being investigated.
These changes are a considerable erosion of the fundamental objective of E2 and E3 zones, being to protect, manage and restore areas with high or special ecological, scientific, cultural or aesthetic values. This is of particular concern given that the reforms apply to one of the most biologically diverse regions in NSW. These reforms are also worrying in the context of the NSW Government’s biodiversity legislation review which from all indications to date is likely to result in further weakened protections for native flora and fauna.
EDO NSW will be running workshops in the Far North Coast region about what the reforms mean for the environment and the community. Find out about upcoming workshops by signing up to our eBulletin.
- Northern Councils E Zone Review Final Recommendations Report
- Northern Councils EZone Review Interim Report
- Aboriginal Elder's court victory is a win for the environment and the community, EDO NSW blog, 9 July 2015
- The Future of Environmental Zones in the North Coast, EDO NSW blog, 4 August 2014